# Run 03 battery material forensics

The selected battery cell still cannot be identified. This work establishes a physically derived minimum active inventory, three explicit cell-recipe scenarios, and a failed collector-model transfer. It does **not** qualify a selected Li5 copper, aluminum, steel or lithium base case.

All quantities use `calculate_balance(..., snapshot="SNAP-RUN02")` and the canonical BOM for `PLANT-GB300-1GW-2026Q4-A`. The architecture and equipment records are unchanged. Files in this directory are additive research records only.

## Preserved plant and physical nesting

| Selected class | Cabinets | Modules | Physical cells, 9S3P/module | Gross cabinet mass, t |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| IT batteries | 7,704 | 138,672 | 3,744,144 | 4,545.360 |
| Facility batteries | 642 | 11,556 | 312,012 | 378.780 |
| Combined B2 incremental | 8,346 | 150,228 | 4,056,156 | 4,924.140 |

The exact current OEM manual specifies 60 Ah nominal cabinet capacity, eighteen series modules, 9S3P/module, LFP chemistry and convective cooling without fans. The exact-family OEM datasheet retained in Run 01.5 specifies **LFP cylindrical cells** (`R15-CLM-E-ENERGYCORE-LI5`). Three parallel cells imply **20 Ah nominal per physical cell**. This is a capacity interpretation, not a cell SKU. Canonical 31.1 kWh/cabinet remains preserved; 518.4 V × 60 Ah = 31.104 kWh is only a rounding check. The unresolved facility UPS interface qualification from Run 01.5 remains.

Cabinet includes modules; module includes cells, busbars, monitoring/balancing electronics, supports, wiring and thermal/insulating materials. Gross assembly, active material, constituent elements and residual are alternate nested views. They are not additive stock categories.

## Physical lower bounds

For the one-electron LFP reaction, one mole of reversible lithium and one mole of FePO4 framework support at most `F/3600 Ah`, where `F = e × N_A = 96485.33212331001 C/mol` from exact SI constants. Thus:

`n_min = physical_cell_count × 20 Ah × 3600 C/Ah / F`

`m_min = n_min × molar_mass`

Using conventional Li 6.94, Fe 55.845, P 30.973761998 and O 15.999 g/mol gives LiFePO4 molar mass 157.754761998 g/mol and theoretical specific capacity 169.893326 Ah/kg. At fixed nominal capacity:

| Material view | Combined battery lower bound, t/GW IT | Base | High |
|---|---:|---|---|
| LiFePO4 fully lithiated active-equivalent | 477.494 | null | null |
| Reversible elemental lithium inventory | 21.006 | null | null |
| Iron in the LFP framework | 169.032 | null | null |
| Phosphorus in the LFP framework | 93.752 | null | null |
| Oxygen in the LFP framework | 193.704 | null | null |

The element rows partition the LFP equivalent; do not sum them with their parent. Lithium consumed during formation, excess active reserve and electrolyte lithium can raise stock above the minimum. State of charge moves lithium between electrodes: the LFP equivalent describes the fully lithiated accounting basis, not a measured installed LiFePO4 phase inventory. These bounds are conditional on ordinary terrestrial conventional atomic masses and the specified LFP redox mechanism. They are not isotope assays or an exact OEM formulation.

The cathode/framework and mobile-lithium budget must be non-copper, non-aluminum and non-steel. Consequently each individual battery upper bound is:

`material_max = 4,924.140 t gross − 477.494 t minimum active-equivalent = 4,446.646 t`

Copper, aluminum and steel individually have **0 / null / 4,446.646 t** outer bounds. All share the same gross budget and cannot be summed. The zero lower bound records lack of a positive quantified coefficient, not material absence. This exposure is too large to dismiss battery uncertainty as immaterial. Nothing allocates the rest to steel.

Total elemental lithium has a separate conservative whole-equipment ceiling: `gross − minimum non-lithium FePO4 framework`. Thus its outer bound is **21.006 / null / 4,467.652 t/GW IT**. This permits lithium in electrolyte, excess active inventory and unresolved components. It does not multiply cabinet gross by the LFP lithium fraction, and its large upper endpoint is a physical exposure ceiling rather than a plausible composition estimate.

The engine-ready `proposed_forensics.json` contains two **COMMON** records, one per exact IT/facility battery BOM class, and six conditional recipe records. COMMON retains 590 kg exact cabinet gross, Faraday minima and explicit whole-equipment bounds with null central estimates. The active-equivalent parent and its elemental views describe one mass budget, including mobile lithium independent of state of charge. Each recipe names the corresponding `replaces_common_id`, so a coherent scenario selects one decomposition per equipment class. Every recipe carries the independent active-equivalent and Li/Fe/P/O Faraday minima and whole-equipment ceilings forward on its existing components, with a null steel bound component; substitution cannot erase those constraints. Active and salt lithium are never added as separate whole-class lower bounds. All eight records pass the current engine validator and physical/nested conservation. COMMON is **ENGINEERED / scenario** for bounds only; no uncalibrated material coefficient enters primary or expanded forensic subtotals.

## Cell-composition scenarios

A new primary [Discover manufacturer SDS](https://discoverlithium.com/s4x_files/resources/sds-lithium-battery-safety-data-sheet.pdf), **Rev T, July 10, 2025**, specifies multiple exact reference-cell recipes. The complete IFR32650 cylindrical recipe is:

| Declared reference-cell category | Mass fraction |
|---|---:|
| LiFePO4 | 27.04% |
| Graphite | 12.78% |
| Aluminum | 6.44% |
| Copper | 9.22% |
| Iron, type unspecified | 23.52% |
| Nickel | 1.18% |
| Polyethylene | 4.37% |
| LiPF6 | 2.01% |
| Organic electrolyte solvents | 13.44% |

These sum to 100% for this reference recipe. The HELIOS ESS GSP71173204F and AES Rackmount GSP50160119F declared recipes sum to 95.05% and 91.22%; missing mass remains residual. The source's statement that metallic lithium is zero does not set elemental lithium in LFP or electrolyte to zero.

The cell reconstruction uses electrical capacity and chemistry before applying the recipe:

`m_active = Q / q_effective`

`m_cell = m_active / declared_reference_LFP_fraction`

`m_material = m_active × declared_reference_material_fraction / declared_reference_LFP_fraction`

Three coherent capacity-utilization cases are retained. Low is ideal one-electron theoretical utilization; base uses the explicit 160 Ah/kg LFP input in [Lechner et al. 2024](https://www.nature.com/articles/s44172-024-00306-0); high uses that same input with the paper's 7.29% initial irreversible capacity-loss reserve, `q_effective = 160 × (1 − 0.0729)`. These are conditional engineering cases, not confidence limits and not a guaranteed envelope for every possible Li5 cell. Additional reserve could exceed the high case.

| Conditional recipe transferred to selected cell count | Cu low/base/high, t | Al low/base/high, t | Graphite low/base/high, t | Cell mass low/base/high, kg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cylindrical IFR32650 | 162.8 / 172.9 / 186.5 | 113.7 / 120.8 / 130.2 | 225.7 / 239.6 / 258.5 | 0.435 / 0.462 / 0.499 |
| HELIOS ESS GSP71173204F | 81.3 / 86.3 / 93.1 | 52.5 / 55.8 / 60.1 | 239.0 / 253.8 / 273.7 | 0.292 / 0.310 / 0.335 |
| AES Rackmount GSP50160119F | 56.4 / 59.9 / 64.6 | 53.3 / 56.6 / 61.1 | 263.2 / 279.4 / 301.4 | 0.346 / 0.367 / 0.396 |

All three have the same explicit active-LFP cases, **477.5 / 507.0 / 546.9 t**. Elemental lithium in this active-equivalent parent is **21.0 / 22.3 / 24.1 t**. In the cylindrical recipe, an additional **1.6 / 1.7 / 1.9 t** lithium view is calculated from the separately booked LiPF6 salt; it is not added to salt gross in the physical sum. The exact electrolyte recipe is not identified for Li5, so none is admitted as selected total lithium.

The cylindrical case retains a **415.3 / 441.0 / 475.7 t iron category**, with the source's unspecified metallurgical identity. It is not steel. The cell recipe alone does not cover cabinet/module busbars, frame, controls or wiring. Subtracting the conditional cell projection from cabinet gross leaves **2,901.6–3,158.3 t**, with 3,049.1 t in the base case. This is a source-calculated residual from the conditional cell recipe; it is not a fully known physical decomposition. The engine separately records known projected cell masses and leaves full physical sum/residual endpoints null where the steel bound-only component has no composition coefficient. The alternatives leave still more unresolved mass.

Every reference/target mismatch is recorded: manufacturer, family, function/rate, capacity, voltage, cylindrical versus unresolved/energy formats, dimensions, gross mass, cooling interface and vintage. IFR32650 is only 5 Ah and has no qualified Li5 supplier lineage; the two ESS recipes are further mismatched. These are **PROXY / scenario** records, excluded from declared/design-qualified copper and expanded forensic copper. Arithmetic precision does not strengthen transfer.

## Validation results

**Exact-family gross partition:** The current Vertiv manual lists 400, 448, 495, 543 and 590 kg at 10, 12, 14, 16 and 18 modules. The endpoint model `gross = 162.5 + 23.75 × modules kg`, trained only at 10/18 modules, predicts withheld 12/14/16 population masses within 0.5 kg, maximum 0.112% relative error. Reported adjacent increments are 23.5–24 kg/module. Applied diagnostically at the selected 18 modules this gives 423 / 427.5 / 432 kg module-associated population and 158 / 162.5 / 167 kg nonpopulation residual. The slope can include shelves and interconnects; the intercept is not measured empty steel. This validates a gross assembly relationship within the exact published family, not an elemental coefficient.

**Measured large cylindrical LFP object:** [Liu et al. 2025's BYD 4680 teardown](https://lescmeng.ai/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Liu_2025_J._Electrochem._Soc._172_110536.pdf) measures cathode foil 5,370 × 69 mm, single-sided areal capacity 2.09 mAh/cm², and full-cell 15.41 Ah. `2 × area × areal_capacity` predicts 15.488154 Ah: **0.507% error**. This validates area/capacity bookkeeping. Measured 10 μm foil geometry reconstructs 35.071 g Cu collector and 10.004 g Al collector, but no independent weighed metal masses validate these coefficients. The source cells' maximum continuous characterization is 2C and their identity is not Li5; target transfer remains unadmitted.

**Failed high-power collector transfer:** The previously captured DOI `10.3390/batteries11010038` paper is **Wätzold, Schlösser, Leistikow and Kowal**, published January 20, 2025, titled *Design Analysis of 26650 and 18650 LFP Cells for High Power and Low Temperature Use Cases*. Historical Run 02 prose misattributes it to Probst; the retained original establishes the correct new metadata. Literal `density × foil_area × reported_currentcollector_thickness` is tested for all five physical objects. Three exceed measured cell gross after adding only the minimum LFP cathode, before graphite, casing and electrolyte. The ANR26650M1B case predicts 65.043 g Cu + 14.631 g Al = 79.674 g collectors against **75.2 g measured gross**. The literal model is rejected. This records a data/interpretation conflict, without asserting a corrected thickness or the authors' intended interpretation.

The active-recipe scenarios have no independent measured Li5 composition calibration. Passing source-fraction and cabinet-gross conservation does not qualify them for the base balance.

## Admission, priority and next evidence

Battery-active material is high priority: the exact design has 259.5606 MWh nominal DC storage and nearly 5 kt of cabinet gross. Battery Cu/Al/steel are material-priority classes because several kilotonnes of physical exposure remain unresolved. Manufacturer cell/module recycling instructions, current module SKU and matched cell SDS or teardown would materially tighten these bounds. Cabinet drawings with actual sheet thickness and busbar geometry could quantify separate structure/conductors without waiting for cell identity.

Strong-evidence battery Cu/Al/steel subtotals: **null**. Expanded forensic battery Cu/Al/steel subtotals: **null**. Outer bounds: available, too wide for provisional closure. Per-material battery status remains **OPEN**. Bulk module and cabinet residual is explicit; semiconductor, civil, extraction and upstream manufacturing scopes are not expanded.

Reproduce offline with:

```sh
python research/run03/battery/derive_battery_forensics.py
```

`evidence.json` includes canonical count lineage, COMMON bound records and recipe scenarios compatible with the proposed Run 03 relation, explicit equations and source claims, nested element views, validation cases, residuals, bounds and admission decisions. `proposed_forensics.json` is the eight-record integration candidate; `proposed_conflicts.json` uses the existing canonical conflict schema for the failed literal collector interpretation. `sources.json`, `claims.json`, `source_manifest.json`, `search_log.json` and captured original PDFs/HTML/text preserve the evidence trail. Raw connected-search captures are in `web_capture.json`. No canonical tables were edited by this workstream.
