# Mass Balance of Intelligence: Run 01 findings

Final snapshot: `SNAP-RUN01-REVIEWED` · evidence cutoff/access: 5 October 2026 · fixed reference: `CFG-GB300-2026Q4`.

**Run 01 extends the equipment and production chain, but cannot close the selected-reference physical material balance.** It establishes more rack components, finished GPU assemblies and embedded logic dies; obtains product-specific material declarations for several upstream equipment classes; and identifies precisely what prevents those declarations from becoming tonnes/GW. The main blockers are a selected electrical/cooling design, qualified component quantities and material BOMs, and semiconductor process yields. A small, explicit CDU design sensitivity demonstrates a reproducible material roll-up. Its mass is confined to those CDU products.

The [README](README.md), supplied [Accounting Standard v0.1](evidence/inputs/accounting-standard-v0.1.docx), complete [Run 00 findings](RUN_00_FINDINGS.md), schemas, source register, ledger, reference, dependency graph, calculations and tests were inspected before extension. All 51 original tests passed. Every original central result reproduced exactly; the full 80-row balance and all 289 original canonical entities still match the [preflight fingerprints](research/run01/baseline/preflight.json). No reference hardware, PUE, reserve or load-factor coefficient was replaced.

The repository now contains 75 sources, 258 claims and 269 retained ledger observations; the reviewed snapshot selects 263 ledger records, including 136 unknowns. There are 11 explicit evidence conflicts, 37 material-component relations, and three current physical-path views. All 74 captured-source hashes match. Source counts include protocols and repeated-source lineage; they are not independent corroboration counts. All 118 tests pass.

## 1. Fixed reference and physical requirements

The reference remains the Supermicro SRS-GB300-NVL72-M1/M0, with 72 B300 accelerators, 36 Grace CPUs, 18 compute trays, nine NVLink switch trays and 72 ConnectX-8 NICs per rack. It is a 2026-Q4 frontier training/research reference, normalized to 1 GW IT electrical capacity. It does not describe a measured campus or an accepted single 1 GW training fabric.

Run 00 assumptions remain unchanged: extra-rack IT reserve 2%/5%/10%; rack input 132/140/140 kW; PUE 1.1/1.2/1.3; electrical load factor 80%/90%/100%. The OEM's 132–140 kW power interval still has an unresolved meter/workload/CDU boundary. Low/high are arithmetic envelopes, not confidence intervals or jointly optimized builds. Counts are fractional normalized equivalents, not purchase orders. The [complete reproduced physical table](build/run01/physical_balance.md) supplies low/central/high and ledger IDs.

| Quantity | Low | Central | High | Unit / boundary | Interpretation |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | --- | --- |
| Rack equivalents | 6,429 | 6,786 | 7,424 | racks/GW, B1 | Unchanged conditional normalization |
| B300 accelerators | 462,857 | 488,571 | 534,545 | units/GW, B1 | Unchanged |
| Grace CPUs | 231,429 | 244,286 | 267,273 | units/GW, B1 | Unchanged |
| Compute trays | 115,714 | 122,143 | 133,636 | units/GW, B1 | Unchanged |
| NVLink switch trays | 57,857 | 61,071 | 66,818 | units/GW, B1 | Unchanged |
| ConnectX-8 NICs | 462,857 | 488,571 | 534,545 | units/GW, B1 | Unchanged |
| Physical HBM | 133.3 | 140.7 | 153.9 | million manufacturer GB/GW, B1 | Physical label retained; usable bytes unresolved |
| Power shelves | 51,429 | 54,286 | 59,394 | units/GW, B1 | New: eight/rack |
| PSU modules | 308,571 | 325,714 | 356,364 | units/GW, B1 | New: six/shelf, 48/rack |
| Finished GPU assemblies | 462,857 | 488,571 | 534,545 | packages/GW, B4 requirement | New assembly-count view of existing GPUs |
| Embedded good GPU logic dies | 925,714 | 977,143 | 1,069,091 | dies/GW, B4 requirement | New: two logic dies/GPU |
| Facility electrical input | 1.10 | 1.20 | 1.30 | GW, cumulative B2 | Unchanged PUE sensitivity |
| Annual facility electricity | 7.71 | 9.46 | 11.39 | TWh/year, B2 flow | Exact central 9.4608 |
| Approximate steady IT heat | 1,000 | 1,000 | 1,000 | MW thermal, B1 attribution | Explicit local heat-conversion approximation |

The [Supermicro rack datasheet](https://www.supermicro.com/datasheet/datasheet_SuperCluster_GB300_NVL72.pdf) and [NVIDIA Blackwell Ultra technical description](https://developer.nvidia.com/blog/inside-nvidia-blackwell-ultra-the-chip-powering-the-ai-factory-era/) support the hardware coefficients (Grade B). Their per-GW descendants retain Run 00's assumption ancestry and remain sensitivities with no empirical evidence grade. Finished GPU assemblies and their embedded dies are nested inventory views, not quantities to add together.

## 2. Electrical architecture: what is required, what is selected

The [generated electrical path](build/run01/electrical_one_line.md) connects enabling supply/HV interface, HV/MV substation, facility MV/LV distribution, protection or buffer choice, PDU/busway/cables and rack power shelves. It has separate facility and backup branches. The equipment classes are supported by inspected primary designs; voltage, ratings, ownership, redundancy and installed quantities remain unselected. Dashed upstream routes show this conditional topology. A protection/buffer class does not select UPS or battery chemistry.

Vertiv's [RD030](research/run01/electrical/vertiv_rd030.pdf), revision August 2025, provides a real GB300 reference one-line: 64 DGX compute racks at 142 kW plus 64 support racks at 14 kW, totaling 9.984 MW IT; four-to-make-three power; eight 2 MVA IT UPS units; separate 2N facility UPS; sixteen 1 MVA PDUs. These are Grade B engineering context. The rack architecture and support allowance differ from the fixed Supermicro reference. Those equipment counts are not scaled to our GW. UPS MVA, protected IT MW, facility MW and utility connection capacity remain distinct. RD030 also contradicts itself about RPP count; the disagreement remains recorded.

A [Virginia SCC Edsall order](research/run01/electrical/scc_edsall.pdf), 8 August 2025, approves four 84 MVA, 230/34.5 kV transformers, a four-breaker 230 kV ring bus, and a 0.9-mile connection for a projected 176 MW campus plus local/future loads. It establishes a real regional topology and shared allocation problem, not a universal transformer/GW coefficient. The 336 MVA aggregate nameplate cannot be divided by customer MW without power factor, contingency, load allocation and expansion reconciliation. Approved future in-service dates are plans, not delivered equipment.

| Selected-reference electrical requirement | Run 01 result | Missing evidence |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Utility connection and substation MVA | UNKNOWN | Parcel, utility study, power factor, firm-contingency and allocation plan |
| HV/MV and facility MV/LV transformers | UNKNOWN count/rating | Accepted one-line, voltage, duty, redundancy and losses |
| MV switchgear/LV switchboards | UNKNOWN | Feeder count, voltage/current/fault ratings, transfer layout |
| IT/facility UPS, batteries | UNKNOWN | Protection strategy, ride-through, redundancy, chemistry and selected BOM |
| PDU/busway/cable quantities | UNKNOWN | Branch topology, voltage/current, route lengths and conductor choices |
| Backup generation/storage/fuel | UNKNOWN | Selected supply/reliability route and its attributable scope |
| Electrical losses | UNKNOWN allocation | Efficiency curves and operating profile, reconciled inside PUE |

One factual interpretation was corrected explicitly: Run 00's power-shelf claim limitation treated “shared 4+4” as demonstrated whole-rack redundancy yielding 132 kW usable. The source does not establish that operating/failure interpretation. Eight 33 kW shelves have 264 kW aggregate module nameplate; the same rack sheet labels total 132 kW and operating input up to 140 kW. Run 01 preserves the old claim, records the conflict, and keeps usable rating unresolved. It leaves the normalization unchanged.

The [separate Supermicro shelf sheet](research/run01/materials/supermicro_33kw_power_shelf.pdf) identifies 50 V DC output, six named PSU modules, 33 kW at 6+0 or 27.5 kW at 5+1, peak 97.5% efficiency and capacitor buffering. Module-level modes do not settle rack-level redundancy. Peak efficiency is not operating loss, and integrated capacitors do not establish a battery-material BOM. Whole-shelf material mass would include its modules; those cannot be added again without reconciliation.

## 3. Cooling, heat and water

The [generated cooling flow](build/run01/cooling_flow.md) preserves direct liquid cooling of high-power components and the external liquid-to-liquid CDU route. It separates residual air, the facility loop, electrical parasitics, final rejection, source withdrawal, circulating coolant, consumption and usable return. No cold-plate count follows directly from GPU/CPU counts: a plate can cover multiple devices.

Liquid heat fraction, air fraction, temperature/pressure/flow requirements, selected pumps, pipe lengths, coolant inventory and final heat-rejection plant remain unknown. Supermicro portfolio “up to 98%” heat capture and a Vertiv DGX thermal split are different architecture evidence; neither becomes the exact Supermicro fraction. The persisted thermal check therefore reports an **open** generation/transport/rejection balance rather than claiming closure.

Supermicro's GB300 page describes an external CDU option up to 1.8 MW and eight racks. A separate in-row SKU sheet gives up to 2.2 MW, 1,560 kg dry mass, 20 kW maximum electrical power and N+1 internal pumps. SKU/revision/rating conditions are unresolved. Run 01 does not multiply the eight-rack grouping by the other SKU's mass. An explicitly isolated grouping sensitivity gives 804/849/929 whole CDU units, with zero additional whole-unit spares only for that calculation; required redundancy remains unknown (`R1-C-S-CDU8`).

A [Carrier verified CDU EPD](research/run01/cooling/carrier-epd.pdf) gives a useful second coefficient chain: a named external liquid-to-liquid unit rated 1.3 MW thermal at **4°C approach temperature**, 13.5 kW rated electrical input and 1,392 kg installed product mass. Its six categories reconcile exactly, with packaging separate. The unit's qualification for the reference remains unresolved.

**Isolated Carrier N-only sensitivity:** provision the full 1 GW IT heat envelope with one independent train and no whole-unit spares, at that declared rating. `ceil(1000/1.3)` gives 770 units. This models installed nameplate provision, not actual liquid capture, operating parasitics, heat rejection or available production. The [scenario protocol](docs/RUN01_SCENARIO_PROTOCOL.md) and named formulas preserve each parent.

| CDU-only design-option material | Quantity | Meaning |
| --- | ---: | --- |
| Stainless steel | 577.215 tonnes | Declared alloy category |
| Steel | 328.513 tonnes | Separate declared category |
| Cast iron | 158.474 tonnes | Kept separate from steel |
| Other undecomposed material | 3.311 tonnes | No element assignment |
| Plastics/nonmetals | 2.387 tonnes | Declared category |
| Electronics | 1.940 tonnes | No copper/trace-element decomposition |
| Total installed CDU product mass | 1,071.840 tonnes | Exact sum of those product categories |
| CDU electrical nameplate | 10.395 MW | Within PUE overhead if selected; no annual-energy claim |

These are one design-option subtotal, not the reference's incremental B2 total. Air handling, facility pumps, piping, coolant, final rejection, building and redundancy additions are excluded. Copper and aluminum are not zero just because the EPD lacks explicit categories. The option uses the existing IT architecture and a compatible functional cooling class; it does not establish a qualified installation.

Supermicro's [2023 tower sheet](research/run01/cooling/sm-water-tower.pdf) describes a closed process loop with a **separate evaporative spray circuit**. Closed circulation therefore does not establish zero consumption. Capacity depends on wet-bulb and operating temperatures. Marketing gallons/minute/MW with incomplete conditions and a newer system-wide 1–50 MW range do not supply an annual Virginia water coefficient or an individual tower count.

Annual source withdrawal, consumption, usable return and WUE remain UNKNOWN. No source/basin/parcel, seasonal profile, heat-rejection route, cycles of concentration, blowdown treatment or return conditions have been selected. No water/query coefficient is investigated. Indirect generation water and dedicated source infrastructure also remain unallocated.

## 4. Material BOM and reconciliation

The [component reconciliation](build/run01/material_reconciliation.md) and [machine-readable roll-up](build/run01/material_reconciliation.json) distinguish coefficient, installed quantity, material result, boundary, source category and design option. The named `material_component` calculation is `component_count × kg_per_unit`. Unselected counts propagate null. A quantified subtotal without a selected component is null, not zero; completeness has no invented percentage denominator.

| Product-specific evidence | Reported material coefficient | Boundary and applicability limits |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Hitachi 40 MVA, 132/15.6 kV ONAN | Copper 5,796 kg; steel 36,573.53 kg/product | B3 candidate, Italian 50 Hz product; selected US duty/count unknown |
| Hitachi 1.6 MVA dry transformer | Aluminum 1,081 kg; copper 30.8 kg/product | B2 candidate, 2022 reference product, 2025 EPD; electrical steel/cast iron separate |
| ABB UniGear feeder panel | Copper 35.22 kg; aluminum 10.57 kg/panel | B2 candidate; breaker/sensors included; packaging separate; registration placeholder retained as a verification issue |
| Schneider Canalis KTA 2500 A configuration | Copper 43.344 kg; aluminum 1,374.624 kg | B2 context for exact 64 m sections plus bends/tapoffs/feed boxes and packaging; historical PEP; not kg/metre |
| Schneider Galaxy VXL 1,250 kW UPS | Explicit copper category 8.466 kg; electronics 317.475 kg undecomposed | B2 packaged-product context; external energy storage excluded; copper category is partial elemental coverage |
| Carrier external CDU | Installed mass 1,392 kg with six category coefficients | B2 candidate; actual reference quantity/qualification unknown; isolated N-only option above |

All are Grade B technical declarations, not measured reference-project BOMs. Schneider OEM download access returned 403; the primary-authored PEP documents were inspected in distributor reproductions. Issuer, retrieval host, date and limitations remain distinct. Canalis's 2020 declaration validity expired in 2025; it is historical product evidence and triggers vintage warnings. No proxy acquires current-product applicability from its evidence grade.

Hitachi's eight listed 40 MVA material categories total 57,341.46 kg against declared 57,380 kg: **38.54 kg remains unassigned**. The residual is retained, not distributed among metals. Four same-rating transformer variants have different copper masses; these are different products, not uncertainty endpoints. Whole equipment, packaging, copper categories, alloys and undecomposed electronics cannot be treated as interchangeable elemental assays.

| Reference material scope | Copper | Aluminum | Steel |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| B1 compute | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN |
| Incremental B2 facility | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN |
| Incremental B3 enabling infrastructure | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN |
| Cumulative B2/B3 totals | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN |
| B4 primary feedstock / extraction | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN | UNKNOWN |

No reference tonnes/GW total is defensible. Missing B1 coverage includes rack frames, compute/switch trays, PSUs, busbars, boards, cables, NICs, cold plates and extra-rack fabric/storage. Missing B2 coverage includes selected transformers, switchgear, protection/storage, routes, cooling plant and structures. Missing B3 coverage includes allocated substations, transmission, generation and water infrastructure. B4 additionally requires process yields, scrap/recovery, recycled inputs and coproduct allocation. Prices, capex and revenue supply none of these physical conversions.

## 5. Semiconductor and manufacturing requirements

The [semiconductor path](build/run01/semiconductor_chain.md) distinguishes embedded finished-good inventory from manufacturing inputs and capacity. NVIDIA directly supports two logic dies/GPU. Reticle-sized does not disclose actual die area or gross usable dies per wafer. No proprietary area, guessed yield or silicon tonne coefficient is inserted.

The reviewed chain is:

```text
embedded good logic dies
  / effective known-good-die retention through qualified assembly
  = required good-die input
  / (gross usable dies per wafer × fabrication yield)
  = logic wafer starts
```

Every factor has a ledger parent. The retention, gross-die map and fabrication yield are unknown, so starts remain null even if one of those later becomes known. Package starts likewise need assembly/test/rework evidence. CPU, host-memory, NIC and switch semiconductor chains remain additional missing coverage.

The accepted HBM stack/die chain remains unresolved because NVIDIA's technical article body says eight 12-high stacks while its correction says twelve stacks. Primary Micron/SK hynix 36 GB, 12-high products support a **separate Grade C capacity-equivalent proxy**: 288/36 = eight stack equivalents and 96 memory-die equivalents per GPU. Central arithmetic is about 3.909 million stack equivalents and 46.903 million memory-die equivalents. The [reproduced proxy calculation](build/run01/hbm_proxy_checks.json) retains source values and functions. It does not establish the B300 supplier/part, base/interface die count, DRAM wafer starts or qualification. A package footprint is not a DRAM die area; relative thinning is not absolute silicon thickness.

TSMC's [2025 annual report](research/run01/semiconductors/tsmc_2025_annual.pdf) distinguishes company-wide 17–18 million 12-inch-equivalent wafer capacity, 15 million shipments, and planned 2026 capacity. These span nodes and wafer sizes. They do not establish available 4NP wafer starts. B300-specific fab/packaging allocation remains unknown. Primary CoWoS evidence connects silicon interconnects, copper and substrates to the production route, but provides no transferable B300 mass coefficient.

| Chain | Requirement | Industry capacity evidence | Available buyer allocation / delivery |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| B300 finished packages | Conditional central 488,571 net assemblies | Portfolio/node/packaging context; no qualified starts conversion | UNKNOWN |
| Logic fabrication | Wafer starts UNKNOWN | TSMC aggregate wafer equivalents; no selected 4NP share | UNKNOWN |
| HBM fabrication/stacking | Accepted stacks/dies/wafers UNKNOWN | Supplier product/expansion evidence; Run 00 allocation disclosures retained | UNKNOWN |
| Advanced packaging/substrates | Net assembly view known; starts/BOM UNKNOWN | Shared CoWoS expansion/constraint evidence | UNKNOWN |
| Transformers/switchgear | Selected counts/rating UNKNOWN | Real operational factories and expansions; no SKU throughput | UNKNOWN |
| CDUs/heat rejection | Reference SKU/count UNKNOWN | Product ratings/EPDs; no production slots | UNKNOWN |

Manufacturing geography is preserved without inventing batch origin. Evidence includes TSMC's Taiwan/global footprint and Blackwell-family production in Arizona; SK hynix Cheongju DRAM/HBM expansion; Micron Singapore/Idaho plans retained from Run 00; Hitachi South Boston, Virginia manufacturing and expansion; Eaton Wisconsin operations and South Carolina planned 2027 production; Siemens Fort Worth operational LV switchboards; and Carrier studied factories in Mexico, Spain and China. None allocates this order or proves qualified delivery.

Run 01 collected clock definitions and state distinctions, but does not force a commissioning date. June 2023 transformer lead-time interviews remain historical context, not October 2026 quotations. Edsall permit-to-target dates and manufacturing construction plans are separate from order-to-delivery and accepted capacity. The 16-edge Run 00 dependency graph and unresolved durations remain unchanged for Run 02.

## 6. Confidence, schema failures and next evidence

| Portion | Qualitative assessment |
| --- | --- |
| Exact per-rack inventories, reported two-die architecture | Strong primary specifications; conditional GW normalization remains explicit |
| EPD material coefficients for exact products | Strong technical evidence within the declared functional unit; partial categories and historical vintages matter |
| Electrical/cooling functional routes | Useful engineering evidence; selected voltage, redundancy, counts and duty remain unresolved |
| Isolated CDU material sensitivity | Reproducible conditional example; qualification, derating and complete facility scope unresolved |
| Actual reference materials, water, wafer starts and buyer allocation | Currently unquantifiable from inspected evidence |
| Primary ore/feedstock requirements | Unquantifiable without process/recycling/allocation reconciliation |

[STANDARD_CHANGELOG.md](STANDARD_CHANGELOG.md) documents ten evidence-driven proposals for v0.2: material identity; product/functional-unit applicability; separate design options; category versus elemental/packaging coverage; thermal/PUE semantics; explicit water flows; production stages and multiple yields; conflict relations; incremental/cumulative roll-ups; and nameplate/redundancy/allocation clocks. The governing v0.1 document is unchanged.

The software extends Git + canonical JSON + Python + generated SQLite. New conflict, material-component and physical-path relations reference the existing common ledger. Independent review exposed material/water relabeling, packaging transfer, lead-only evidence leaking into subtotals, and missing cross-geography/thermal checks. Fixes and adversarial tests are documented in [RUN01_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md](docs/RUN01_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md). Review also appended explicit water-return/flow interpretations and assembly-retention parents. The actual initial built `SNAP-RUN01` remains historically queryable; `SNAP-RUN01-REVIEWED` is the final report membership.

The [47-question unknowns queue](UNKNOWNS.md) identifies why each gap matters, current/missing evidence, likely resolver, effect, priority and falsifier. The highest-value next evidence is an accepted rack input/failure test and exact B1 material BOM; an owner-approved facility one-line with redundancy and route geometry; qualified cooling/heat-rejection design and source/return conditions; and B300 fabrication/assembly/stack yields plus reserved supplier allocation. These gaps are separate: selecting a design cannot supply a missing material assay, and obtaining an EPD cannot select its installed quantity.

Reproduce both runs with `python scripts/reproduce.py`; test with `python -m unittest discover -s tests -v`. The [Run 01 artifact manifest](build/run01/manifest.json) and [preservation check](build/run01/preservation.json) make the resulting coverage and limits auditable.
